OK this question's bothering me

Why on earth would any bro post a fake report???

I mean, this forum is extraordinary valuable
It's

• even faster than CNN
  
• even more fun than youtube
  
• even more accurate than a Which? report
  

... so why mess with it?  

It's not that way by accident either - it's good entirely because of extraordinary dedication and hard work of a bunch of volunteers.  So why would anyone
  a) think they can get away with a fake report?
  b) disrespect the readers by trying to cheaply mislead them?
  c) disrespect everyone who makes a genuine report by abusing their right to post?  

Beats me ... the vast majority of reports here are 100% genuine, original, and a valuable contribution.  But, a few are not.  

... since we've not discussed it here before, I'm expect your strong contribution ...

What's your take?  Any insight into this sort of  behavior?

I feel getting to the next RA access is too simple an explanation for this serial offender in our midst.  Here is what I think:

In the very beginning, I think it was a case of a NEWBIE wanting to get to RA30 as fast as possible (note: this guy posted more than a hundred posts in a single day to achieve that goal).   

After it didn't work and he caught Karma bombed, he tried a different means.  "Why don't I try to get there just as quickly through reports and get approval and recognition at the same time?"  A case of a NOBODY trying to be a SOMEBODY (though we are all nobodies in fact as we are anonymous to the vast majority of contributors).  One problem, however.  He wanted to post real reports but couldn't, whether it was due to financial constraints, impotence, sexuality, age or something else.  Eventually, he was caught out and labelled a "c..nt".  

Then his aims changed.  Getting RA is no longer that important.  Now it's personal.  He's now disgruntled and knows he is being watched and gets off on deceiving others.  He also wants to see how far he can go before getting caught - get spanked, if you, from a person of authority - here it is Twice-a-Week.  He is a loner who craves for attention, possibly because a strong male figure was lacking in his childhood.  

I hope that helps.

As TwiceAweek has on the Poll section, they aren't even bros they are 'CUNTS'.

I haven't been here long but I try to contribute with facts on my few reports, I hope other bros can experience the goods and not repeat the bads from my experiences.

Are we dealing with a bunch of schoolkids on summer vacation, who have vivid imaginations of what pussy is? Then keep dreaming 'CUNTS'.

i def hope the reports i read or that it is being supplied won't be a fake, or else the reports will actually lose meaning to it.
The reports are provided by friendly users on this forum to inform us on their experience and whether or not they believe it is worth it. All the reports i've read so far have provided a lot of valuable information. so thank you for everyone that took time out of their busy life to commit to this
I def wouldn't dare to write a report unless i actually had the experience.
I think that this type of behaviour is unacceptable, how ever it's really hard to judge which ones are real or not considering the amount of reports this forum has.

but thank you everyone for giving us their insight

Newbies post all the time asking how to get reading access.  We tell them to participate and file reports.  So I guess they do...  even if they have no experiences to report.

Have fun, CGP

I can only think of two reasons -

1. They're boosting their posts to get access to restricted areas since the FAQ says to post reports, and they just come up with something on the fly.

2. They're being "rewarded" to give good reviews? I'm thinking "perks" for good ratings, possible?

Or maybe they're too bored and doing this to waste their time...

Troll .........

I don't agree that any newbie would make up a fake report to get points.  It's soooo much easier just responding to a report for that.  Think about it.  Spend 10 minutes making a report or 10 seconds making a response.  I think it's because they are trying to promote one of the WGs and write a good report so that she gets more customers.  Don't forget, this forum gets a lot of readers that just browse through the site but does not participate.  If a WG gets a very well written report, she will probably get a good influx of new customers for a short period of time.  This promotion technique is also free.  Just my opinion guys.   But this is a very interesting question to start with.

and that's exactly the point.  It is hard to spot a fake report.  It is especially hard for a newbie or a guest to spot a fake, so inevitably they suffer most from misleading or dishonest reports.  Which is why this forum is so valuable, since the vast majority of respondents are genuine and sharing insights and information only they have.  

Hey, there's nothing intrisically wrong about creative fiction.  There's also nothing wrong about using other people's photos as long as they gave permission.  But there's a very fine line between writing entertaining literature and passing off a fake as a genuine piece of information.  The reality is that a single fake report damages the credibility of the entire community, and continues to damage it as long as it is not marked as "fiction" or removed.  

We all know that of course.  

The question here is why the **** should anyone want to post a misleading or outright fake report in the first place???  

If the intention is good, here's a chance to declare it.

Hunter has it in a single word - Troll.

Some people seem to delight in being trolls, and you find trolls in every forum of every kind, from political forums, to movie forums, to whatever. I don't know exactly why they do it. I have simply assumed that they are people that for whatever reason get some sort of personal entertainment from thinking that they have deceived other people with their posts, that tricking people is somehow 'funny'.

Perhaps they think that if they succeed in deceiving large groups of people, that this act somehow stands as a  testament to their own superiority, and validates them as someone who is of superior intellect. Perhaps their (most likely unconscious) logic goes that if they can succeed in tricking a large group of people, they must surely be smarter than them... and if they can rile people up, then even better.

So perhaps the trolls like to feel clever. And I say 'most likely unconscious logic' because I doubt any of them actually put any critical thought towards why they do what they do.

Personally, I try not to feed the trolls, though on a forum like this, just the presence of a troll report is enough to do damage, whether you feed that troll or not.

And lastly, all trolls are arseholes and deserve a swift kick to the balls. Repeatedly.

EDIT:
Oh! I was just perusing another section of this site and I believe I now know where this subject stems from! Haha! That guy has some serious issues... he goes beyond being a mere troll, he is some kind of special troll that I have no words for... I think he might need professional help.

[ Last edited by  mxq at 3-8-2009 14:37 ]

You reckon!!!  The understatement of the year.

Why don't we name them and shame them?? That will stop fakes from posting??

I have been around for a year but I do find that a lot of the pictures are being RAed 30. I don't know why i feel that way or maybe there are just more pictures that go along with reports nowadays. I think G-A-R-Y was the pioneer who elevated the standards of reporting with pictures. as a result, it does become frustrating not to be able to see the pictures. I believe the original intent was to post some garbage and get a promotion in status.

Now I think he gets an adrenalin rush just to see how much time everyone is wasting on him. we must not fall in his trap. if it is from the same ip address, then i would ban without reason.

ML

hey your post was rewarding with 1 money, i never seen that before!

Yeah not sure how I did that ...

I think you're capturing an important point there bro.  

Certainly RA is used for two reasons.  Partly a genuine need for more sensitive pics to be posted, or a desire to share with a smaller circle.  And it is an equally genuine enticement to encourage more active contribution from bros who have something to say but need an incentive.  

The irony is there's no need to post fake reports.  It seems self-evident there are LOTS of ways to post material - chat, jokes, debate, questions, etc. - all of which is very welcome and actually outnumbers the live reports and pics by a considerable margin.  

A newb who wants RA can very quickly achieve it without ever writing a single line about himself, so confidentiality can be 100% preserved while still being a full and active participant.  

Of course, live reports are the most popular, and get the most credit.  

Now, I can see someone trying it on ... as you say we've created a incentive, and some bright spark is inevitably going to try a short cut ...

But to write a fake report, and then continue to defend it when challenged, has me beat.  Just too weird for my simplistic brain ...

like i said he's trying to capture attention, let's not dwell on this topic or else we will fall into his/her trap bro

ML

I still believe they are trying to advertise WGs.  It's the cheapest way to draw attention since the forum gets so many hits.  Perhaps there can be another section open in the forum for the WGs to advertise themselves.  This way there won't be anymore fake reports.  In addition, this may attract even more readers.  Readers are interested in reading about our experiences with WGs but they may also have a high amount of interest reading WGs describing their own services.  I believe this would capture a whole new set of contributors while also capturing a whole new set of audience.  

You may never know.  WGs describing themselves might turn out to be more interesting than us describing our experiences with them.  Just something to think about.  I would love to hear what other members think.

Nah.  We call those "writers".  It's pretty obvious when someone is promoting a girl, and yes promotional posts are also moderated, just as other spam is.  In any case, a promotional article on a REAL girl is still about a real girl ...

... the question is specifically why would someone write a fake report, using completely fictional names places and events, taking  photos from another website?  As odd as that sounds, it happens.  

BTW there IS a place in the website for WGs to promote themselves, here:
http://www.sex141.com/en/main.php

And yes, we do occasionally get girls posting - but few of them get into much of a debate, and we have yet to see a full report from a lady.  When it does happen, we can celebrate a new milestone!!  

My observation is surprisingly few girls even monitor the db or the forum at all, come to that - OK few of them can read English, but they don't seem to pay attention to the Chinese side either.  Given how important it is to their business, you'd have thought they'd dive in and share their point of view any time there's a report about them ... but I've not seen it happen yet!

by the time they punch the english words into their electronic dictionaries to read one report they would've fucked 5 guys

ML