scootermonger
Erotic Emperor
Rank: 6Rank: 6


UID 46801
Digest Posts 0
Credits 2855
Posts 1260
Karma 2814
Acceptance 823
Reading Access 60
Registered 19-6-2010
Status Offline
Post at 30-8-2013 01:00  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Watches

I'm interested in buying an entry level luxury watch.  I'm not a banker, real estate tycoon, or a rich kid, so I've got's to spend carefully.  There are a couple watches that I'm looking into, on the higher end is the IWC Portugese and on the lower end is a TAG Carrera blackface, with a couple others thrown inbetween.  

So my question for you guys is.... Do any of you guys have experience with these two brands?  If so, how do you feel about them.  My second question is what's the best place to purchase these type of watches in HK.  I know there are lots of watch dealers in HK, but is there any you guys would specifically recommend?  Also.. what about 2nd hand watches, any good sources?

Thx

Scoot


 Attachment: Your usergroup does not have permission to access attachments
Top
jake.houston
Master Mongerer
Rank: 8Rank: 8


UID 93098
Digest Posts 0
Credits 6884
Posts 610
Karma 6748
Acceptance 2715
Reading Access 80
Registered 21-7-2012
Location USA
Status Offline
Post at 30-8-2013 10:47  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
I've always been a fan of TAG watches.  I've not owned IWG but a friend swears by them and the do look stylish in my opinion.

Not sure where to get the best buy in HK.

J




“I believe that sex is one of the most beautiful, natural, wholesome things that money can buy.”
― Steve Martin
Top
kaleu
Throbbing Titan
Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7


UID 45445
Digest Posts 0
Credits 3308
Posts 1512
Karma 3224
Acceptance 1672
Reading Access 70
Registered 24-5-2010
Location PRC
Status Offline
Post at 30-8-2013 14:53  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Top
Nomis
Carnal Conqueror
Rank: 3Rank: 3



UID 72942
Digest Posts 0
Credits 305
Posts 34
Karma 303
Acceptance 40
Reading Access 30
Registered 23-8-2011
Status Offline
Post at 3-9-2013 09:12  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Go for the IWC!! Rather spent Some more money and appreciate your masterpiece every single day for the rest of your life then having bought a slightly above average watch.especially with a portuguese you cant do anything wrong. in my humble opinion an elegant and timeless watch.   in switzerland (where i live) the 3 most well known watch retail stores also sell 2 hand watches. you get the same watch with a 25 to 35 % discount. so i would go for a 2 hand watch if i were you. no one can tell the difference and you get a great masterpiece for a reasonnable price. when i was in hk i remember seeing 2hand watches in those highend 2 hand clothes stores. but since im not a local i can only suggest you; that you rather save up some money and take your time finding your watch otherwise you are going to regret it one day.
Top
heymikey
Carnal Conqueror
Rank: 3Rank: 3



UID 31690
Digest Posts 0
Credits 383
Posts 163
Karma 377
Acceptance 122
Reading Access 30
Registered 26-9-2009
Location Hong Kong and NYC
Status Offline
Post at 3-9-2013 10:57  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Actually, likely not much different any more...

I don't want to share too much personal info, but I am a rather "avid" collector of vintage wristwatches... I own a few hundred of them which I rotate periodically so I wear every one I own.  The most modern watch I own came out in about 1980...so when it comes to specific new models I am rather useless.  That said, in general, I know that vintage IWC watches were much better than TAG... all else being equeal, that is.  If both are mechanical watches, then they both likely use a very similar ETA movement... though Tag does still use a few other movements inferior to the ETA movements as well as some quartz movements.  IF either movement is a quartz... then I'd suggest avoiding it all together and look for a REAL watch instead.  (And please do understand that when it commes to quality modern mechanical watches, the majority of all makers use proprietary variations of the SAME basic ETA movements... perhaps one of the BIG reasons that I like my watches from 1910 to 1960.)

UPDATE:  I just noticed that this TAG mentions on the dial that it has a Caliber 1887 movement.  If memory serves, thsi is because the Swatch group (which owns ETA and many watch brands) has stopped shipping as many movements to many makers -- including Tag.  Therefore, the Cal 1887 is a customized version of the Japanese Seiko movement.  While Seiko movements are okay, for $3000+ I would MUCH rather have a ETA Valjoux movement because I know that EVERYONE can fix it and locate parts if they are needed in 20 years. That said, I know that some people LOVE this Tag-customized Seiko movement... and might also say that the ETA ebouche movements are not as good as this movement.   Frankly, the original 1960s Tag Carreras came with an original 3 dial Valjoux (ETA) movement... so I imagine that the modern movements were held back for a reason.  IF you like this look, I'd suggest that you look for a vintage Tag Carrera with the Valjoux movement.

For more info on IWC and their movements, please see:
http://forums.watchuseek.com/f35 ... plained-256887.html

For more info on the Tag movements used:
http://forums.watchuseek.com/f25/tag-movements-217172.html

[ Last edited by  heymikey at 3-9-2013 11:25 ]

Recent Ratings
scootermonger   5-9-2013 02:21  Acceptance  +4   thx
Top
scootermonger
Erotic Emperor
Rank: 6Rank: 6


UID 46801
Digest Posts 0
Credits 2855
Posts 1260
Karma 2814
Acceptance 823
Reading Access 60
Registered 19-6-2010
Status Offline
Post at 5-9-2013 02:20  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Reply #5 heymikey's post

Thanks for the info, what I really should do is just steal my bosses Bovet ( giant gold minute repeater gaudy looking thing ) and call it a day haha.  

Since I'm new to this watch thing, I'm not too familiar with the history of watch movements.  The Tag that I was looking at does get a lot of flack for being a fake luxury watch from various websites.  A couple months back I was looking into some vintage IWC's, they were pretty sweet, but I was worried about being able to keep it maintained in China.
Top
heymikey
Carnal Conqueror
Rank: 3Rank: 3



UID 31690
Digest Posts 0
Credits 383
Posts 163
Karma 377
Acceptance 122
Reading Access 30
Registered 26-9-2009
Location Hong Kong and NYC
Status Offline
Post at 6-9-2013 04:21  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
If you are in HK there are a couple of places that have nice vintage pieces rather reasonably priced.  One is a little watch shop in about a 4x8ft booth over about 3 blocks from the Peninsula Hotel... across street and down a bit from Langham Hotel.  (I will try to walk over and confirm it is still there.)  There is also a very nice vintage shop over in Central.  There used to be one in a gallary arcade beside the Sheraton but I THINK it was gone the last time I stayed there.  

As far as getting service in China, depending on where you are I would feel MUCH safer having an old vintage serviced most places than a new mechanical.  And if you do pick a ETA or similar movement from 1960-1990, chances are that just about anyone good can (and have) service them -- and getting a replacement movement if you ever need one is also not likely too difficult.  BTW, if you are going to buy vintage watches, I would suggest getting an extra movement in most calibers you own anyway since this will likely in the long run be a lot cheaper than looking for parts only some day.

Recent Ratings
scootermonger   6-9-2013 17:49  Acceptance  +4   thx
Top
beautifulasian
Banned




UID 107609
Digest Posts 0
Credits 48
Posts 56
Karma 44
Acceptance 70
Reading Access 0
Registered 19-7-2013
Status Offline
Post at 6-9-2013 11:38  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
How about the new Samsung Watch? Can take photos, surf the web, email ... a whole new level. More than just the time.. a lot more.
Top
heymikey
Carnal Conqueror
Rank: 3Rank: 3



UID 31690
Digest Posts 0
Credits 383
Posts 163
Karma 377
Acceptance 122
Reading Access 30
Registered 26-9-2009
Location Hong Kong and NYC
Status Offline
Post at 6-9-2013 12:56  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Reply #8 beautifulasian's post

LOL beautiful asian, you ARE kidding, right?  The only watches I own with a battery came out in 1964 or before.  ;)
Top
scootermonger
Erotic Emperor
Rank: 6Rank: 6


UID 46801
Digest Posts 0
Credits 2855
Posts 1260
Karma 2814
Acceptance 823
Reading Access 60
Registered 19-6-2010
Status Offline
Post at 6-9-2013 17:50  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Reply #8 beautifulasian's post

It's ugly as sin, especially that camera sticking out the strap... i'd rather just use my phone.
Top
Frenchexpat (Faites chier la vache)
Kinky King
Rank: 5Rank: 5


UID 69773
Digest Posts 0
Credits 1252
Posts 639
Karma 1234
Acceptance 366
Reading Access 50
Registered 14-7-2011
Status Offline
Post at 6-9-2013 18:08  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Haha the samsung is ugly! No way I would wear that!

IWC all the way in your 2 options. They are more stylish than the Tags (sorry but ai consider the Tags as too tacky....).
Top
milkystain
Musky Member
Rank: 2



UID 62945
Digest Posts 0
Credits 187
Posts 87
Karma 185
Acceptance 39
Reading Access 20
Registered 28-3-2011
Status Offline
Post at 14-9-2013 17:31  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Def go for the IWC. Tag isn't even an option in my opinion.
Top
n1k0la5
Carnal Conqueror
Rank: 3Rank: 3


UID 74225
Digest Posts 0
Credits 372
Posts 71
Karma 369
Acceptance 63
Reading Access 30
Registered 9-9-2011
Location Europe
Status Offline
Post at 20-9-2013 15:44  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
A friend of mine collects watches per se invests in watches like other people invest in property. if you want to get a watch that will increase in value, and want to be able to say buy up, he would suggest Phillipe Patek, and about a 10000 US$ starting budget. He used to have the largest IWC collection in private hands and sold them to work on his current Patek collection.

So based on that I would stick with the IWC,
Top
timewaster
Erotic Emperor
Rank: 6Rank: 6


UID 7180
Digest Posts 0
Credits 2778
Posts 1944
Karma 2755
Acceptance 467
Reading Access 60
Registered 14-1-2008
Status Offline
Post at 22-9-2013 21:54  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
don't patek go for around 50-100K?
i don't think they have any watches for 10K

Recent Ratings
scootermonger   23-9-2013 00:53  Acceptance  +2   i thought the same, there is no 10k patek.
Top
nikolakos
Nookie Newbie
Rank: 1



UID 109646
Digest Posts 0
Credits 0
Posts 3
Karma 0
Acceptance 3
Reading Access 10
Registered 23-9-2013
Status Offline
Post at 23-9-2013 16:09  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Go for the IWC bro, it's a solid watch which will only appreciate in value. Tag is OK too but no match for the IWC. I'm a collector and this is my advice.
Top
nikolakos
Nookie Newbie
Rank: 1



UID 109646
Digest Posts 0
Credits 0
Posts 3
Karma 0
Acceptance 3
Reading Access 10
Registered 23-9-2013
Status Offline
Post at 23-9-2013 16:09  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Go for the IWC bro, it's a solid watch which will only appreciate in value. Tag is OK too but no match for the IWC. I'm a collector and this is my advice.
Top
davemust
Nookie Newbie
Rank: 1



UID 109655
Digest Posts 0
Credits 77
Posts 15
Karma 76
Acceptance 29
Reading Access 10
Registered 23-9-2013
Status Offline
Post at 24-9-2013 23:58  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
hi TS! Im a watch fanatic myself and before you ask yourself which to buy, i can see you love chronographs as well just like me, and prefer a clean dial with no frills on the bracelet or tacky leather.
if you are not a watch enthusiast, durability-wise you'd honestly not go wrong with either brand. they are both well made except of course IWC has far superior finishing with little here and theres.

I noticed however that your watch choices are in different price brackets. The IWC is pretty much 2x the carrera!
Thus id like to give you advice to ask yourself first:

1. Is this watch going to be a daily beater in my rough job?
        If you may get rained on, be in humid work places, bang your wrist here and there, you might feel scared about your IWC Portuguese.
        for a beater the carrera will fare better and try exploring bracelet models in case you work humid places.

2. IWC is like a "leftist" brand, that tries to evoke a "we are not mainstream", esp from their quite simple, yet elegant designs compared to say very distinct rolexes and flashy breits/Audemars, etc.
    The joy of owning an IWC is knowing not a lot of people know it and will recognize it but you know its special. Kinda works both ways as its not so greedy on the eyes. Altho they are fast growing as a brand now.

3. Tag is tried and tested a true workhorse watch. Great for everyday and servicing wont be as bad in case you need to. However doesnt hold much of a brand esteem vs all the others. You really buy it for its functionality

4. There are other everyday entry level luxury model chronographs you can explore such as:
           Omega Speedmaster 3573 - True Classic tool watch everyone knows and recognizes. a must as well in a watch collection. Manual-Winding movement also a joy to wind each day its like winding your hard earned $$
           IWC Pilot Chronograph 3777 - Very simple and bold at the same time. A bit flashier though because of its size but nonetheless a great entry level watch into the IWC world with a tried and tested movement as well           Zenith El Primero 36,000 VPH 42mm - Beautiful watch and you will get cheers from watch cllectors and horologic afficionados because of the legendary movement. However I feel it doesnt look too everyday-ish an                feels scary to wear wherever.
           

5. Buy from a boutique and/or canvas in all the big major store chains. Kenn Watches etc. In my opinion, the shadier stores only offer about 2-3k HKD max difference from normal stores and to me, that is not a risk worth taking esp for a luxury item that u want to enjoy your hard earned $$ for.  Dont buy something u cant afford as they say.

Do update me and you can IM me as well!
Top
 


All times are GMT+8, the time now is 13-11-2024 14:47

Powered by Discuz! 5.0.0 © 2001-2006 Comsenz Inc.
Processed in 0.048221 second(s), 9 queries , Gzip enabled

Clear Cookies - Contact Us - 141Love
Disclaimer: This forum is operated as a real-time bulletin board system. 141CLUB.COM carries no legal liability on its contents. All messages are solely composed and up-loaded by readers and their opinions do not represent our stand. Readers are reminded that the contents on this forum may not convey reliable information thus it is readers' own responsibility to judge the validity, completeness and truthfulness of the messages. For messages related to medical, legal or investment issues, readers should always seek advice from professionals. Due to the limitation of the forum's real-time up-loading nature, 141CLUB.com is not able to monitor all the messages posted. Should readers find any problems regarding the messages, do contact us. 141CLUB.COM reserves the rights to delete or preserve any messages and reject anyone from joining this forum. 141CLUB.COM reserves all the legal rights.