‹‹ Last Thread | Next Thread ››

Poll Trade Reward Activity

oscarmandude Carnal Conqueror UID 32785 Digest Posts 0 Credits 318 Posts 252 Karma 317 Acceptance 13 Reading Access 30 Registered 15-10-2009 Location USA Status Offline

#1 Post at 1-9-2010 12:22  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L banning cantonese programs iin Guangzhou i thought China was receptive toward cantonese that has flourished over decades compared to 50 years of history of communist china.  Why would the government officials be so naive to think banning Cantonese tv programs to promote Asian games and strictly mandarin? i was excited about the language of mandarin and was interested in learning it. now this seems absurd and i am beginning to have seconds thoughts of because how inappropriate the proposals by government officials towards language. They play favorism on official dialect mandarin over the other. If it weren't for Hong Kong, Macau, Shenzhen, Taiwan, Guangzhou... for their economic base and chinese unity and contributions. China wouldn't have advanced to it's present status as emerging economic super power. Just a food for thought. http://en.secretchina.com/news/3877.html

12uronin Carnal Conqueror UID 39371 Digest Posts 0 Credits 331 Posts 77 Karma 325 Acceptance 111 Reading Access 30 Registered 5-2-2010 Status Offline

#2 Post at 1-9-2010 13:09  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L The Chinese government should know by now that they should choose their battles. It would be terrible strategy to alienate so many members of the Chinese diaspora by attacking their language. On the bright side, Cantonese is the perfect language for articulating anger. lol So a big "diu lae lo mae hum ga chan" to the People's Congress! Recent Ratings CunningLinguist   1-9-2010 22:43   Acceptance   +1   DLLMHGC - LOL!

haroldla Banned UID 23978 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1157 Posts 795 Karma 1156 Acceptance 10 Reading Access 0 Registered 24-4-2009 Status Offline

#3 Post at 2-9-2010 03:00  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #1 oscarmandude's post I agree what you said... but i thought the govt had already declined they had this intention already.

escritic (Just a teddy bear) Throbbing Titan UID 3478 Digest Posts 0 Credits 3423 Posts 1679 Karma 3356 Acceptance 1335 Reading Access 70 Registered 2-10-2007 Location West Coast Status Offline

#4 Post at 2-9-2010 07:46  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L More than you would think... from participating in the Chinese side of 161 and 141 sites, I have observed that there are many mainland China loyalists in Hong Kong, or China nationalists. This is what I often get. "If you are Chinese and can read and write Chinese, why are you writing in English instead of Chinese?" " Fuck the westerners (gwai lo) and be true to your Chinese heritage." "Learning English is nonsense. We are Chinese and should only need to learn Chinese." However, they failed to realize that the prosperity of HK came from the union of both Western and Eastern cultures. And English WAS the official language of Hong Kong until 1974 and Chinese became the official language as well after. Offering BFE to the chosen ones

haroldla Banned UID 23978 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1157 Posts 795 Karma 1156 Acceptance 10 Reading Access 0 Registered 24-4-2009 Status Offline

#5 Post at 2-9-2010 14:56  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #4 escritic's post i have to say language is a tool for me to communicate, so it is important to learn more different languages to broaden your explosure and English is an international language, so it is very important to master this language. I think people in the Chinese forum saying that mainly because many people in there don't know English well, so this is why they just use Chinese to communicate.

Mackfg Carnal Conqueror UID 27458 Digest Posts 0 Credits 334 Posts 171 Karma 331 Acceptance 57 Reading Access 30 Registered 9-7-2009 Location Kowloon Status Offline

#6 Post at 2-9-2010 17:26  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Yes, I saw that about the protests. I do not understand why they try and push Mandarin so hard. As a cantonese speaker it really upsets me that they feel like they need to do this. Cantonese is the language of Guangzhou and they shouold respect that. The purpose of doing this for the Asian games. I do  not think switching to mandarin will help them promote the sport at all. I think leaving the Cantonese and showing the area the way it is naturally is a better way to promote themselves.

twiceAweek Sex God UID 1044 Digest Posts 0 Credits 21117 Posts 20505 Karma 20541 Acceptance 11525 Reading Access 110 Registered 12-4-2007 Status Offline

#7 Post at 2-9-2010 18:55  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #1 oscarmandude's post is this a mongering related question ? in fact, is this a question ? why is this posted in the Q & A when it should be in Chat ???

bonkers89 Lustful Lord UID 25160 Digest Posts 0 Credits 829 Posts 703 Karma 819 Acceptance 192 Reading Access 40 Registered 19-5-2009 Status Offline

#8 Post at 2-9-2010 23:15  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Is the ban supposed to be a short term thing or a long term thing? I'm so surprised too. Why don't they ban Shanghainese from being spoken in Shanghai? and same goes for the hundreds of other dialects all over the country! I generally support the govt because it usually has some sort of reasoning, even if it is cruel to some. However this one just completely boggles my mind.

haroldla Banned UID 23978 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1157 Posts 795 Karma 1156 Acceptance 10 Reading Access 0 Registered 24-4-2009 Status Offline

#9 Post at 3-9-2010 20:11  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #8 bonkers89's post actually based on what i heard many young generation of Shanghainese have already don't know how to speak Shanghainese. I won't be surprised 20-30 years later, young generation of cantonese people might be don't know how to speak cantonese too if we don't keep promoting cantonese.

bonkers89 Lustful Lord UID 25160 Digest Posts 0 Credits 829 Posts 703 Karma 819 Acceptance 192 Reading Access 40 Registered 19-5-2009 Status Offline

#10 Post at 8-9-2010 22:44  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #9 haroldla's post I'm not sure about how widespread shanghainese is. Is it limited only to Shanghai and surrounding area? The case of cantonese may be different in that there is a much larger population which includes the entire Guangdong province, HK, some parts of Guangxi, and probably others which I don't know. That could amount to a decent % of the entire population of china. The political power in the north has always made Guangdong 2nd place in its decisions, but this is definitely going too far!

haroldla Banned UID 23978 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1157 Posts 795 Karma 1156 Acceptance 10 Reading Access 0 Registered 24-4-2009 Status Offline

#11 Post at 9-9-2010 01:28  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #10 bonkers89's post don't get me wrong. i agree what you said. the role of cantonese is more important and far more historical than mandarin. and not only people in HK or guangdong province speak cantonese, there are sooooo many oversea chinese speak cantonese too.

nyc101 Carnal Conqueror UID 24141 Digest Posts 0 Credits 399 Posts 295 Karma 397 Acceptance 38 Reading Access 30 Registered 28-4-2009 Status Offline

#12 Post at 9-9-2010 01:39  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Getting rid of Canto is kinda crazy.  I dont think it can ever happen as long as HK/Guanzhou region is prosperous and there's a vibrant media/cultural/art scene - be it with TV, movies, art, etc.  If some of the smaller European countries can hold on to their languages, how can we not hold on to Cantonese.  I'm sure there are a lot more people speaking Cantonese than Czech or Polish!

haroldla Banned UID 23978 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1157 Posts 795 Karma 1156 Acceptance 10 Reading Access 0 Registered 24-4-2009 Status Offline

#13 Post at 9-9-2010 01:43  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #12 nyc101's post i agree!!! knowing how to speak cantonese was a fashion icon 20 yrs ago. even 10 yrs ago, if you speak mandarin with cantonese accent - many gals will love you immediately.

bonkers89 Lustful Lord UID 25160 Digest Posts 0 Credits 829 Posts 703 Karma 819 Acceptance 192 Reading Access 40 Registered 19-5-2009 Status Offline

#14 Post at 10-9-2010 23:20  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L yea culture-wise, HK is still a strong force. Lots of ppl on the mainland still watch HK movies and listen to HK music. Hopefully that will be enough of a force to make cantonese stick around....

bonkers89 Lustful Lord UID 25160 Digest Posts 0 Credits 829 Posts 703 Karma 819 Acceptance 192 Reading Access 40 Registered 19-5-2009 Status Offline

#15 Post at 10-9-2010 23:22  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #13 haroldla's post haha... i consider speaking mandarin with a cantonese accent to be a turn-off!! though I absolutely love northern girls speaking cantonese with a mandarin accent! perhaps thats sort of like a double standard....

CRE Nookie Newbie UID 45324 Digest Posts 0 Credits 21 Posts 21 Karma 21 Acceptance -1 Reading Access 10 Registered 21-5-2010 Status Offline

#16 Post at 11-9-2010 01:45  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L I believe cantonese will never die, don't think even Chinese govt can ban cantonese mandarin is just a little time if compare to cantonese

haroldla Banned UID 23978 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1157 Posts 795 Karma 1156 Acceptance 10 Reading Access 0 Registered 24-4-2009 Status Offline

#17 Post at 11-9-2010 03:03  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #15 bonkers89's post hahahaa... i think it really depends on when u are talking about. 10-15 yrs ago, i use my cantonese mandarin to speak to gals in mainland, they love to hear and said i am sooo cute and love me so much. but if still use the same kind of cantonese mandarin to speak to gals in first-tier cities, the gals will look me down first..... good time flies sigh.......

escritic (Just a teddy bear) Throbbing Titan UID 3478 Digest Posts 0 Credits 3423 Posts 1679 Karma 3356 Acceptance 1335 Reading Access 70 Registered 2-10-2007 Location West Coast Status Offline

#18 Post at 11-9-2010 05:17  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #17 haroldla's post Do you think it is because people in mainland China make more money now compared to people in HK? Offering BFE to the chosen ones

haroldla Banned UID 23978 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1157 Posts 795 Karma 1156 Acceptance 10 Reading Access 0 Registered 24-4-2009 Status Offline

#19 Post at 12-9-2010 03:07  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Reply #18 escritic's post yup you are right. therefore they want to deal with very inner circle people nowadays and they will look you down if your mandarin is not good enough - i mean no accent level.

Poll Trade Reward Activity

All times are GMT+8, the time now is 26-11-2024 10:52

Disclaimer: This forum is operated as a real-time bulletin board system. 141CLUB.COM carries no legal liability on its contents. All messages are solely composed and up-loaded by readers and their opinions do not represent our stand. Readers are reminded that the contents on this forum may not convey reliable information thus it is readers' own responsibility to judge the validity, completeness and truthfulness of the messages. For messages related to medical, legal or investment issues, readers should always seek advice from professionals. Due to the limitation of the forum's real-time up-loading nature, 141CLUB.com is not able to monitor all the messages posted. Should readers find any problems regarding the messages, do contact us. 141CLUB.COM reserves the rights to delete or preserve any messages and reject anyone from joining this forum. 141CLUB.COM reserves all the legal rights.