Originally posted by TheButler at 3-5-2011 12:24
It's possible of course, but has never happened to me in all my BB anal adventures (with girlfriends). And yes, you can get poop on your peter. For me, each girl is very different. I've had girls that didn't feel any better than vaginal sex, and then girls that could make me double climax in their ass. It's all very individual, and more often than not, the girls didn't want all the extra lube, just their own juices. Go figure!
Same here. No UTIs in my BB anal experiences (with girlfriends and FB). With one, lube was needed as she was super tight. With the rest, extra lube needed only when dry, otherwise natural lube (from pussy) or saliva was sufficient.
Also had a girlfriend who was a virgin and who abstained from sex due to her religious beliefs. When I jokingly suggested anal instead, she surprisingly agreed. So of course I happily went along with it
I guess she enjoyed it enough that within the month, I popped her other cherry as well

So much for abstinence.
Now, not trying to suggest anything untoward her, but has anyone experienced a reluctant anal partner (reluctant before the act) who turned out to enjoy it? I've had girls who said they won't do anal, that it's dirty, painful, they've never done it, they don't want to do it, etc... But during vaginal sex, when I finger their anus, they seemed to enjoy it, even with my finger inside. And then despite earlier protests that they don't do it, when I try to stick it up their ass, they don't do anything to stop it, and when I'm going at it up their bum, they suddenly seem to enjoy it and asked me to pump harder, faster & deeper. The first time it happened, I was taken by completely by surprise. There I was, trying to be gentle, when I get instructed to go for it HARD.