This is a round up of some of the professional reviews for the new iphone so far. Apart from a few small quibbles, such as being tethered to AT&T in the U.S., they would seem to be all giving high marks.
iPhone 4 verdict: Apple does it again
ASHER MOSES
June 23, 2010 - 3:43PM
The big US tech reviewers have delivered their verdicts on the iPhone 4 and all offered resounding praise, hailing it as the hottest smartphone around right now.
Apple's new device goes on sale in the US on Thursday, and is expected to arrive in Australia late next month.
Walt Mossberg, of The Wall Street Journal, said the iPhone 4 was enough to keep Apple in the lead in the smartphone wars.
"In both hardware and software, it is a major leap over its already-excellent predecessor, the iPhone 3GS," he wrote.
"While its 3.5-inch screen, once considered huge, is now smaller than those on some other smartphones, the high resolution packs in a lot of material and makes text appear almost like ink on fine paper."
Mossberg was impressed with the iPhone 4's new iOS4 operating system, which adds missing software features such as "limited multitasking (the ability to run apps simultaneously); folders for grouping related apps; and, for email, a unified inbox for multiple accounts and the ability to present messages as threaded conversations".
Existing iPhone owners were this week able to upgrade to iOS4, but many iPhone 3G owners complained the update process was extremely slow and error-prone.
Engadget described the new device as "the best smartphone on the market right now". Notably, its chief rival, Gizmodo, does not appear to have been given a review phone, having most likely fallen out of favour with Apple after buying a "stolen" iPhone 4 weeks before launch and revealing most of its secrets.
"The combination of gorgeous new hardware, that amazing display, upgraded cameras, and major improvements to the operating system make this an extremely formidable package," wrote Engadget.
The New York Times's David Pogue remarked on the iPhone 4's fast processor and thin design, which consists of two glass slabs on the front and back wrapped by a stainless-steel band. Apple claims the new phone is 24 per cent thinner than its predecessor and has the world's highest-resolution smartphone screen at 960x640.
"The result is beautiful, and since there's no more plastic, it feels solid and Lexus-like," Pogue wrote.
Pogue said the iPhone 4, with front and rear cameras, was the first phone to make "good video calls", thanks to Apple's FaceTime software. But you'll need to be in a strong Wi-Fi hotspot and both ends of the call need to be using an iPhone 4.
And he also noted that voice calls have been improved, "thanks in part to a noise-cancelling microphone and an improved audio chamber".
Battery life has benefited from the new design, with Boing Boing's Xeni Jardin getting four days of juice under light use and a full day under heavy use, including video recording and playback, instant messaging, email and data tethering.
Jardin tested the camera, which includes a built-in flash, extensively and described the speed at which you can take shots "nothing short of stunning". She liked the ability to tag photos and videos by location, allowing users to browse their shots plotted on a map.
"The higher definition video [720p] is spectacular, and far better in quality than what was possible with iPhone 3GS (or, as far as I've seen, with any smartphone)," Jardin wrote.
USA Today had only minor issues with the device, such as the lack of Flash support, lack of removable battery and the inability to expand memory.
"Cutting through the hype, Apple has given long-time diehards, and first-time iPhone owners, plenty to cheer about," reviewer Edward Baig wrote.
The only major downside mentioned in many of the reviews was AT&T's slow and congested network, which frequently drops calls. This is only a problem for US users and largely exists because Apple insists on offering the device exclusively through AT&T.
Others were critical of the limited multitasking, which works only with certain apps. Apple says this is done to conserve battery life.
"iOS4 permits multitasking of certain important functions - for example, internet radio can keep playing, and GPS apps can keep updating, while you work in other programs. Other apps go into suspended animation when you switch out of them," wrote Pogue.
Link here:
http://www.smh.com.au/digital-li ... 8x.html?autostart=1