I know we have several punters here who are big fans of ANAL (Dr. A is the leader of the pack).  I'm curious about everyone's experience with anal sex... it is preferable to vaginal or oral sex for some of you?  If so, why?  I'm not a big fan of Greek myself, but have participated in a handful of anal encounters, most because the girl really enjoys it and specifically asks for it.  

Recently, I've experienced some SA girls who will begin to "offer" up anal right after reaching a certain comfort level with me, usually between 3-5 dates.  These are mostly from "submissive" girls who really like to please.  One SA girl who insists on covered FS has offered me anal "uncovered" and said it was OK to cum in her ass   

Some seem to genuinely "enjoy" anal while others you can tell it's uncomfortable for them.

Thoughts?!  Experiences?!!

I have only ever did it once or twice with WG's, never with an SO as it does not interest me. I am an oral fan tbh.

My first anal experience was with a WG in UK, she asked if I wanted it and I thought "Why not??" but I just didn't see why it was so good.

My only anal experience was with Tatiana.  It didn't really feel that different to be fair.  I certainly don't feel the same kind of warmth from regular FS.  I'm also constantly worried that some shit will pop out and give me a facial while going at it doggy.  This thought on the back of my head makes me feel uneasy.

If I visit her again and she asks me to do it, I think I would decline.

Done it a few times. It has always seemed uncomfortable for the girl with one exception.

A couple of the ladies clearly wanted it over asap, which I was happy to do.
Another two were clearly in pain, but gave the impression that they were also enjoying the experience - wanting me deeper, faster, slower, calling the shots and prolonging the experience.
One of them had rears in her eyes when I came, and then hugged me like crazy, kissing my neck and dfk for five solid minutes before hitting the shower.

The girl who really seemed to get off on it was a lovely lady who works out of a place I used to visit in Hornsby, north of Sydney. Her regular offers of "20 dollars, fuck my bum?" occasionally wore me down. She liked to allow rear access in mish, her arse raised up on a pillow, and she wanted it hard and fast and deep she'd finger herself wildly and grunt low, animal grunts whn she came... She's still on the rosted, but I don't get to Hornsby too often these days.

Do I enjoy anal?
Yes.
Not every time, even if it's offered, but every now and then it feels... I don't know... dirty? Dangerous? Dominant? All these things. The sensation of getting slowly through the sphincter, negotiating your way into a pace, a rhythm... Give it a try, Bros!

Be very careful when doing anything penetrative without protection.

http://goaskalice.columbia.edu/a ... anal-sex-other-stis

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15189783

https://www.avert.org/hiv-transmission-prevention/unprotected-sex

I've not tried anal, I've initiated anal play, but not actually had anal sex...but have spoken to some experts in the area. Here are the takeaways I got from them.
1. Unless you know absolutely, uncovered anal sex is a bad idea.
2. Unless she has prepared for you, anal sex can result in fecal matter following your exit. So unless you want to see brown bits on your nether bits.... Cover up.

I've yet to encounter a gal who passes both 1&2, hence I've never followed thru with anal sex.... I don't even want to see brown bits on my raincoat. Lol

~UD

Really weird for me tbh. It's too tight, to a point where I can't feel anything down there and it's really not that pleasurable. It's like getting a HJ but with an extremely tight grip.

Also I really don't trust anyone, even non-WG, to keep their asshole clean enough for me to really want to do it.

For those who enjoying anal sex (being the penetrator), do you also enjoy rimming / finger up your ass / prostate massage / dildo up your ass?  

I'm not trying to be facetious, but just wondering if there is an overall fascination with the a-hole...

I have done anal several times. First time was with my GF many years ago. She enjoyed it much more than me as she liked the male to be the boss in the bedroom. A bit of slave / master I guess.

Done it with some working girls when I am insanely horny and down and dirty but for me it doesn't feel so great.

Give me a nice warm wet pussy any day...

Obe

I am an anal virgin.   and often think about breaking that. But I also feel a WG is not really the best way to try it out, unless she's a regular and you're both comfortable with one another. Just my opinion as everyone has different comfort levels.

Never had the luck of being offered someone's ass either. That said there were many times when I slipped out of my SO and it plowed into her butt hole, only for her to scream out in anger.   A real mood killer.   

Thirty years ago (nearly pre-AIDS days when I rarely wore a condom )  I had a one night stand with a girl who went to town on my arsehole, before I even knew what the word "rimming" meant. I must say, like a lot of things that are spontaneous, it was fucking heaven.  

Have tried it a couple of times but mainly with GFs. Getting offered it on a one nighter seems to be hitting the jackpot as its pretty rare over here.

I am no anal expert, only had anal sex a few times. The last couple of times were in Bangkok, Thailand (both were reported here, albeit with a higher RA setting), and I have to say I rather enjoyed it these both times. In both cases the WGs were quite the pros in this area, completely clean and had excellent muscle control. So I think it can be nice experience if the girl knows what she's doing. Needless to say, always covered.

And I do also enjoy rimming and receiving anal play.

I only did anal with wgs that offered this as a service and are.comfortable with it. I've never pushed for it.
Beside the different feeling more Pse, more tight,   I admit I like the view of LB going in A Hole in various positions. But it is very occasional, I am really a classic sex type punter.

I am a ass lover, more than the hole,  I worship good ass cheeks so I usually stick to grabbing and eating them.

I also enjoy a lot AR, got it many times specially in Chinese Fs saunas,  a standard service there.
But I never asked or let a girl do anything more such as Dildo or fingering, not my thing. I used Dildo on some anal wgs tho, specially for preparation.

On one single occasion, I let myself go and licked the a hole outside area, caught up by the moment, but that as far as I went.

Anal is nice - but never ever unprotected. Guys, be carful. This with your brain!

I have a regular punt who like you say is quiet and submissive and offers anal.

Love her butt and cut little ass, funny as my relationship is so good I probably could get it for free but we have too much fun with everything else.

Beyond the kink factor I’ll take a hot pussy

Bizarrely, I don't think I have ever had anal with a WG (may be wrong but I don't think so) and its never top of my list even though I have nothing against it.  Sex parties with civvies don't count, right?

Bizarrely again, I think I have had anal sex with every SO (ex-wives, 1yr+ GFs and 1 LT SA) which was always instigated my the girl as an experiment to push the boundaries so became a sort of once a month thing when the mood was to get really down and dirty (not literally.....lol).  Was fine for me and no poopoo experiences.

I have no issues with a bit of rimming either way, though (I will stop saying bizarrely now.......) WGs tend to get more into it, literally ;-) , as they are used to it and you are expecting the paid service while SOs are a bit more of a quick flick of the tongue before back to the balls.

An SO slipping a gentle finger up the ass while giving a good BBBJ as you cum is sublime but I find WGs try to fuck you with their finger to get you over the line asap.

Overall, nothing against it, not top of my list, only with a girl who is genuinely into it and it has always been BB for me with SOs who are tight so the feeling of gently popping the bell-end through the sphincter and using that as the friction point as you pump away has always got me off.  May be a different feeling with a 2mm Trojan cap on.

All in my experience and YMMV.

I have never been interested in anal whatsoever and have no interest in trying it at all.  I prefer girls sucking my lb or pounding my lb into their ls.

Never done Anal but would try if a wg offers it. Hopefully it will be a good experience
I am an ass man and don't mind dipping occasionally into a clean, sweaty ass hole.

Ironically never been offered anal from a WG, but a girl a Kama Spa let me put my entire index finger in her but to play around   

It was only 3 days ago that I did anal the first time with my girlfriend. It's awesome because it's very tight compared to vaginal sex (I don't think there'll ever be a girl whose pussy is tighter than her anus  )

Further the feeling of the penis inside the ass or vagina is quite different and pleasureable

Best of all for my girlfriend no need to have condom or worry about getting her pregnant!

She enjoyed it and cumming in her ass while doing anal missionary is one of the highlights of my sex life haha.

I was expecting it to be like a JAV where the cum drips out of her ass but I cummed quite deep and perhaps not enough to see it drip out.

Interesting - some of the replies here really made me pause and think about it - so appreciate reading all the responses.  I am definitely a fan - it can be amazing if you are intimate with an SO... covered and with WG loses some magic.  The best experiences in the dark arts for me were those really intimate moments, pushing the boundaries and trusting, becoming closer ..rather than just pounding some A wildly (which is fun  - don't get me wrong)...but lacks the warmth and wetness of the other one.. now... doggy with a finger or two feeling your girth stretching a wet pussy is another thing.. best of both worlds.