‹‹ Last Thread | Next Thread ››

Poll Trade Reward Activity

richjiii Nookie Newbie UID 105659 Digest Posts 0 Credits 36 Posts 8 Karma 36 Acceptance 8 Reading Access 10 Registered 20-5-2013 Status Offline

#1 Post at 8-7-2014 18:54  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Language question I have been to Macau and Hong Kong before and had a great time.  I told a buddy about it and we are visiting on a mongering trip to both HK and Macau late November.  I would like to be able to speak a little of the local language. In your opinions would it be better to learn Cantonese or Mandarin? Mainly to talk to the WGs but also be able to ask simple questions etc.

ggherkin Kinky King UID 99550 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1870 Posts 1400 Karma 1776 Acceptance 1883 Reading Access 50 Registered 9-12-2012 Status Offline

#2 Post at 8-7-2014 21:00  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L I take my hat off to you if you can add any variant of Chinese in that amount of time. I know it took me a lot longer, and my Chinese is still extremely broken. In HK and Macau, Cantonese will work fine, of course, but I think it is harder to pick up. There's also the notion that if you are going in to China on a future trip, Mandarin could be very useful, and not just for punting. When it comes to sex words, I've found that most girls in HK and Macau can decipher my attempts to speak either Mando or Canto, even if they are only fluent in one of those. The sex vocabulary is not that large. I've found that people generally appreciate the effort to speak their language, even if all it does is make them smile or wince. Bottom line: Either, but I'd do Mandarin for the other benefits. Gherk Recent Ratings yoyotam   8-7-2014 21:09   Acceptance   +1   i second that what you said !

richjiii Nookie Newbie UID 105659 Digest Posts 0 Credits 36 Posts 8 Karma 36 Acceptance 8 Reading Access 10 Registered 20-5-2013 Status Offline

#3 Post at 10-7-2014 19:37  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L re: language question Thanks ggherkin! There is a place here in NYC Chinatown that offers a "vacation survival Chinese" course.  I spoke to them (minus the mongering part) and they offered Cantonese but recommended Mandarin because they thought it would be easier to learn and  I would be able to travel to other places in China in the future and there are more Mandarin speakers coming to America so I could keep in practice here.

ggherkin Kinky King UID 99550 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1870 Posts 1400 Karma 1776 Acceptance 1883 Reading Access 50 Registered 9-12-2012 Status Offline

#4 Post at 10-7-2014 23:57  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L Get yourself a Chinese girlfriend with a sister. Out of self-defense, you'll be learning Chinese in no time Recent Ratings yoyotam   11-7-2014 11:45   Acceptance   +1   "a girlfriend with a sister" lol !

kaleu Throbbing Titan UID 45445 Digest Posts 0 Credits 3308 Posts 1512 Karma 3224 Acceptance 1672 Reading Access 70 Registered 24-5-2010 Location PRC Status Offline

#5 Post at 11-7-2014 11:32  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L In the past, most of the Chinese going to America spoke Cantonese.  Maybe that is changing now.  I don't know.  Personally, I think Cantonese is easier, but Mandarin is more useful. I would go for a Mandarin class, but unless you are super dedicated or gifted in languages, you aren't going to learn much by November.  Still, give it a try. Recent Ratings SneakingAround   11-7-2014 13:42   Acceptance   +1   Agreed, but make the decision based on where you plan to spend more time: HK or mainland.

ggherkin Kinky King UID 99550 Digest Posts 0 Credits 1870 Posts 1400 Karma 1776 Acceptance 1883 Reading Access 50 Registered 9-12-2012 Status Offline

#6 Post at 11-7-2014 12:07  Profile P.M.  Font size: S M L And don't forget ... when it comes to language, immersion is always the best way. Immerse yourself in someone Chinese, and see if you agree with me Gherk

Poll Trade Reward Activity

All times are GMT+8, the time now is 28-11-2024 07:11

Disclaimer: This forum is operated as a real-time bulletin board system. 141CLUB.COM carries no legal liability on its contents. All messages are solely composed and up-loaded by readers and their opinions do not represent our stand. Readers are reminded that the contents on this forum may not convey reliable information thus it is readers' own responsibility to judge the validity, completeness and truthfulness of the messages. For messages related to medical, legal or investment issues, readers should always seek advice from professionals. Due to the limitation of the forum's real-time up-loading nature, 141CLUB.com is not able to monitor all the messages posted. Should readers find any problems regarding the messages, do contact us. 141CLUB.COM reserves the rights to delete or preserve any messages and reject anyone from joining this forum. 141CLUB.COM reserves all the legal rights.