Subject: U.S. Businessman’s Chinese Legal Nightmare
  This thread has been closed by sexyloser at 18-5-2024 11:10. 
atomic3d
Throbbing Titan
Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7


UID 41127
Digest Posts 0
Credits 3282
Posts 2642
Karma 3157
Acceptance 2501
Reading Access 70
Registered 10-3-2010
Status Offline
Post at 24-12-2012 17:16  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
U.S. Businessman’s Chinese Legal Nightmare

U.S. Businessman’s Chinese Legal Nightmare Includes Torture, Lawyers Say

And yet the terrible irony of this case is that Wus American citizenship offers him no protection because he entered China using his Hong Kong ID rather than his U.S. passport.

That fateful decision has allowed the Chinese government to ban all access from U.S. consular officials, since China does not recognize dual-nationality.

http://www.thedailybeast.com/art ... re-lawyers-say.html
Top
temp19782005
Nookie Newbie
Rank: 1



UID 87534
Digest Posts 0
Credits 2
Posts 36
Karma 0
Acceptance 36
Reading Access 10
Registered 4-4-2012
Status Offline
Post at 13-2-2013 22:22  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
The implication is: if you have an HKID card and a US passport.  Do use the latter to enter China. You will enjoy more protections.
Top
Petay_1283
Fucking Legend
Rank: 10Rank: 10Rank: 10


UID 46298
Digest Posts 0
Credits 11574
Posts 3139
Karma 11375
Acceptance 3975
Reading Access 100
Registered 9-6-2010
Location Hong Kong
Status Offline
Post at 20-2-2013 10:36  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Reply #2 temp19782005's post

Please forgive me for sounding stupid here...

I have a British Passport - I thought I had to actually use this regardless to enter China?

I also have a HKID.




'Yes, Madam, I am drunk, but in the morning I shall be sober and you will still be ugly.'
Top
meeni
Lustful Lord
Rank: 4



UID 60996
Digest Posts 0
Credits 701
Posts 308
Karma 691
Acceptance 191
Reading Access 40
Registered 21-2-2011
Location Hong Kong
Status Offline
Post at 20-2-2013 22:26  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
You cannot enter China with a HKID card. You have to enter China with a Mainland Entry card or a passport.
Top
doghead (dog)
Erotic Emperor
Rank: 6Rank: 6



UID 16705
Digest Posts 0
Credits 2985
Posts 2230
Karma 2893
Acceptance 1832
Reading Access 60
Registered 2-12-2008
Status Offline
Post at 20-2-2013 22:58  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Mr. Wu was tempted by that common Chinese philosophy in life, 'must do things the fastest way, be efficient with time so I can have more time to play mahjong'...(snarky)

So instead of waiting for at least 30 mins to an hour to cross immigration with his passport, he would rather use his 'Return to Village' pass and stroll through immigration in 5 mins. How can we blame this guy because I am always envious of those who can walk fast through immigration while I stew in line at the passport control?
Top
Petay_1283
Fucking Legend
Rank: 10Rank: 10Rank: 10


UID 46298
Digest Posts 0
Credits 11574
Posts 3139
Karma 11375
Acceptance 3975
Reading Access 100
Registered 9-6-2010
Location Hong Kong
Status Offline
Post at 21-2-2013 08:32  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Reply #5 doghead's post

Yeah, I use my HKID at HK side then my passport at China side.

I love going through with my boss as he has an APEC card and we can go through the special lane




'Yes, Madam, I am drunk, but in the morning I shall be sober and you will still be ugly.'
Top
saudi
Nookie Newbie
Rank: 1



UID 49059
Digest Posts 0
Credits 7
Posts 9
Karma 7
Acceptance 9
Reading Access 10
Registered 30-7-2010
Status Offline
Post at 21-2-2013 21:59  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Reply #2 temp19782005's post

That is not always possible. My wife is dual national (HK and foreign) and could not get a China visa with her foreign passport as the issuing agency seemed to know that she has a home return permit. Once you have that you'll have to enter China without consular protection. Even my son (age 2) who never had a SAR passport was denied a visa and we've had to get an SAR passport and home return permit for him.
Top
doghead (dog)
Erotic Emperor
Rank: 6Rank: 6



UID 16705
Digest Posts 0
Credits 2985
Posts 2230
Karma 2893
Acceptance 1832
Reading Access 60
Registered 2-12-2008
Status Offline
Post at 22-2-2013 00:35  Profile P.M. 
Font size: S M L
Reply #7 saudi's post

I think the issue is that HK is part of China and China does not recognize multiple nationalities. Since your wife holds a Home Return Permit and possibly a SAR passport, China considers them her only 'valid' documents, the foreign one does not count.

I am guessing your son was born in HK which would mean he is an automatic HK citizen...citizen of China until you apply for a foreign passport for him.

I know people who qualify for the Home Return Permit, but do not get it because it would mean giving up their overseas passports which many are very reluctant to do so.
Top
 


All times are GMT+8, the time now is 11-11-2024 07:08

Powered by Discuz! 5.0.0 © 2001-2006 Comsenz Inc.
Processed in 0.045808 second(s), 10 queries , Gzip enabled

Clear Cookies - Contact Us - 141Love
Disclaimer: This forum is operated as a real-time bulletin board system. 141CLUB.COM carries no legal liability on its contents. All messages are solely composed and up-loaded by readers and their opinions do not represent our stand. Readers are reminded that the contents on this forum may not convey reliable information thus it is readers' own responsibility to judge the validity, completeness and truthfulness of the messages. For messages related to medical, legal or investment issues, readers should always seek advice from professionals. Due to the limitation of the forum's real-time up-loading nature, 141CLUB.com is not able to monitor all the messages posted. Should readers find any problems regarding the messages, do contact us. 141CLUB.COM reserves the rights to delete or preserve any messages and reject anyone from joining this forum. 141CLUB.COM reserves all the legal rights.