I’ve been using 141 for a few years and have lurked the forums, but finally decided to make an account and start posting. Sharing is caring, after all.

So my question, which has been addressed elsewhere to a degree but I would still like to get community opinion on is this: how recent should a report be in order to be considered good, actionable, and post-worthy? Even though I didn’t post things here, I keep a little black book and have been writing things in it for quite some time. I don’t think anyone wants my report from some random walk up a year ago, but is it of interest to this board if I were to post, say, some great punts from my trip to Bali in December if I still have contact info from the girls (and in one case, spa)? Would a girl that I saw a few months back be fair game as long as she’s still in HK and reachable? I've written down lots of details in my personal...diary of sorts...and would be able to easily make a full report. But would that be considered flooding for Karma?

Just hoping for your two cents.

It has always been my opinion (my personal opinion, some other senior members seem to have a different one), that reporting past experiences can also be a useful report.
Like you say, I would not bother reporting on some random walk-up experience, but any memorable or unusual experience that can make up an interesting report, or an experience that others on this forum can learn something from, is worth reporting.
This is especially true these days, when many of us are unable to practice the hobby, and there are much fewer reports.

Just my opinion, I think if you report an establishment, the time frame can be much longer. I can't imagine the establishment changing too much aside from the girls.  But if the place trains the girl right they usually will give a similar level of service.  Walk-ups on the other hand are more time sensitive, since the girl is most likely gone after a couple of weeks, but if you have their contact/location then that timeline extends as well since bros can still find them.  For less reported places, like your Bali trip for example, I would love to read about since I'm always looking for new places to go

Of course if you have a great story, timeline doesnt really matter either. I think many members here would enjoy a good read regardless of how long ago it was  

In short, for me personally, anything other than a random usual walk up where the girl is long gone with no contact is the only thing not worthwhile..